User talk:Hillgentleman/20070610172201
What I did was fine. Check :special:whatlinkshere/template:譯緊 - there is nothing. 編輯
- 有嘢講：/Comment： Wikicantona, The message on my page Cellular automata was wrong. Thus I changed the redirect. I checked the special:whatlinkshere/template:譯緊 before the edit. No page was actually using the redirect. Nobody has used it. Perhaps never. And I was the only author.
If we don't change it now, it would create confusion in the future. Thus en:Wikipedia:Ignore all rules and en:SNOW. --* :)---Hillgentleman | 書 , 二零零七年六月十號(星期日), 格林尼治標準 09點30分12秒
- 有嘢講：/Comment：
Sorry, misunderstanding. I was not talking about template:重譯緊 which is fine. The problem is with Template:translation. You changed template translation created confusion!!!, Many links to that [1]. The change you made is this one [2] which I feel problematic.
I am not saying that because it's always been and then should not be changed. Changes should also be considered the consequences of it. That is, the confusion introdues into the tagged article. At the least the changes should follow the wiki process (to reach consensus, for this one I believe you have the right move). At least one can do, when changes that template, make a note and correct the page links to it... anyway...
--WikiCantona 2007年6月10號 (日) 10:01 (UTC)
Please be specific. Where is the problem? 編輯
- 有嘢講：/Comment： I did only two things: 1. introduced the variable. 20070610093012 - see m:help:variables for its use; 2. deleted two redundant words 積極.
--* :)---Hillgentleman | 書 , 二零零七年六月十號(星期日), 格林尼治標準 10點08分56秒
- 有嘢講：/Comment：
Since the article may has been translated into half way, now the template translation really confuse the reader about the article. Is it translating or just what I need to do. The modification of the template:translation change "the rule of the game in the middle of it". It is not fair to reader and author of articles whose intend only to say it is translating.
e.g. 英國國籍法與香港 the template:translation is intend to say "translating" since the use of translation is the same as translating before you make the changes. The problem is introduced by your changes. Wikipedia:問 after pressing the link...the blank page is confusing... Pages with these problem are many. okay.
--WikiCantona 2007年6月10號 (日) 10:54 (UTC)
This is due to the edits by user:shinjiman after mine. 編輯
- 有嘢講：/Comment： The cause is this edit [3] and thereafter.
--* :)---Hillgentleman | 書 , 二零零七年六月十號(星期日), 格林尼治標準 11點26分45秒
- 有嘢講：/Comment：
Thank you for your info. I will ask Shin... Sorry for bothering you.
I know what you mean. Proposed solution: new template 編輯
- 有嘢講：/Comment： Let us have a new template, called template:translate, and revert this to the old one. I cannot read Zhong Men at this moment.
--* :)---Hillgentleman | 書 , 二零零七年六月十號(星期日), 格林尼治標準 11點31分29秒